Bottled Water or Tap Water

When I first saw bottled water, it made absolutely no sense.  Who in the world would pay for water when they can have it free at home?  I always thought what a waste of money; am still drinking tap water and feel just fine.

However most people fell for the fancy bottled water.  Likely they must be thinking, whoa, expensive water, must be top of the line, most pure water.  Nowadays, most everyone is drinking bottled water.  In fact, every year we consume billions of gallons of bottled water.

There seem to be certain benefits to it.  It’s convenient to carry around; it’s calorie-free, refreshing and no doubt healthier than sugary soda pop.


WHERE DOES IT COME FROM?

Surprise, surprise.  While some bottled water might even come from sparkling springs, a good part comes from a municipal supply.  The bottlers aren’t required to list the source on the label.  Whatever they do say on front of the label is a sales pitch aimed at the consumer.

I don’t buy bottled water so can’t verify this, but Reader’s Digest states that Aquafina was going to begin stating on their labels that its water comes from public water sources.  And Nestlé PureLife bottles will indicate whether the water comes from public, private or deep well sources.  Dasani acknowledges on its website, but NOT on the label itself, that it draws from local water.

ISN’T BOTTLED WATER SAFER AND CLEANER?

No. In fact, all the majority of evidence shows that it’s worse for you. Plastic leaches into the water it holds, which has been linked to health issues like reproductive problems and different types of cancer. Harmful hormone-disrupting phthalates leach into the bottled water we drink after as little as 10 weeks of storage, or much faster once the bottles have been left in the sun (like in the car)

Tap water isn’t perfect either because the purity varies depending on where you live, but the same could be said for bottled water.   If you wanted to check out how your local water system rates, click here.

SAFETY REGULATIONS

The EPA regulates tap water, while the FDA oversees bottled.  However there is a loophole.  FDA oversight doesn’t apply to water packaged & sold in the same state which amounts to 60% to 70% of bottled water to be free of FDA regulation.  In this case scenario, testing depends on the states but they often don’t have adequate resources to oversee bottled water.

Even though the FDA requires bottlers to regularly test for contaminants, the agency considers bottled water a low-risk product, so plants may NOT be inspected every year.

DOESN’T IT TASTE BETTER?

In blind taste tests, people had trouble differentiating between tap water and bottled water, and it’s virtually indistinguishable once poured through a simple filter.  Your best bet, as Huffington Post says, is using tap water run through a good filter on your kitchen tap or drinking container, which will yield you the cheapest, cleanest and most convenient water source.

ISN’T BOTTLED WATER A RIP-OFF?

You bet it is.  You pay more for a gallon of bottled water than you do for a gallon of gas.  Yet everyone complains of high gas prices, while having no problem paying for water that you can get out of the tap for free.  I am going for the tap water.

WATER BOTTLERS FIGHT BACK

On my last shopping trip I checked a few brands of bottled water.  Dasani uses a PlantBottle concept originally introduced by Coca-Cola.  Dasani claims that their bottles are recyclable which is supposed to reduce carbon emissions.  However upon closer look you’ll see that Dasani bottles are only up to 30% recyclable.  That “up to” part sounds quite vague.

Nestle PureLife claims that their bottled water is “purified” and “enhanced with nutrients for taste.”  I’m glad they don’t assert that said nutrients are significant for health benefits.  This “nutrients” part is definitely aimed at boosting sales.

SOME OTHER PRODUCTS ARE PACKED IN PLASTIC

Have you noticed?  Lots of other products have been packed in plastic for the longest time.  Such as ketchup, mustard, barbecue sauce and other condiments, salad oil, drinks like Gatorade, soda pop, some juices, milk and some produce.  I bought blueberries that were packed in a flimsy plastic box.  Ditto for strawberries and some greens.

And I’ve been cooking batches of food that I store in the freezer so for a while I don’t have to cook at all, and always thought high of this.  Now might be rethinking.

 

Advertisements
This entry was posted in bottled water, drinking water, Health, plastic bottles, sparkling springs, tap water and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Bottled Water or Tap Water

  1. I think that it was the Italians who started the all idea of drinking mineral water instead of tap water. In the nineteen fifties Italian marketers started to convince people that drinking mineral water was good for their health and in particular for their livers. Many Italians then were worried about the health of their livers because they ate far too much food at lunch so that was how the all craze started.
    Then in the sixties Italians started to export bottled waters abroad together with Parma ham, mozzarelllas and other foods or drinks, and so the mania for drinking bottled water instead of tap water spread out all over the world.
    I must say though that in Italy we have very good mineral waters that are strictly certified to come from well known springs. Moreover all Italian mineral waters were and maybe are still sold in glass bottles.
    Elsewhere nowadays the great majority of bottled water is sold in plastic containers and I believe that it can cause health problems as well a great environmental damage.
    I admit that I use only bottled water, though, as you rightly say it’s probably a waste of money. Having said it tap water can taste good or bad according to where one drinks it from.
    Lately I go to a restaurant where they serve me a glass of water as soon as I sit down and I must say that it tastes even better than bottled water, so I will most probably start to drink it from the tap.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thanks for commenting and for the insight into the history of mineral water. Having read that, I would like to (maybe) taste real Italian Mineral Water one day.

      Your drinking only bottled water is fine by me. Each to their own, and we all agree to disagree. I am pretty open on that. I too drink iced water when going out to eat, and at home, too, especially in view of the upcoming hot days.

      Thanks again.

      Liked by 1 person

  2. dray0308 says:

    My wife and I decided today to stop buying bottled water due to the plastic. Great read!

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Thanks for the comment!

    Like

  4. Gus Bluejay says:

    This is a great post! I totally agree! I don’t know if you have seen it already but “Tapped” is a great documentary about bottled water.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s